Board Thread:News and Announcements/@comment-14908162-20180130171542/@comment-26239285-20180131092844

Thanks for looking at that. I guess (sigh) we can't rely on CC translations then. However, we should not be making any statements about their quality because they could turn out to be a good translation.

My opinion then is that the guidelines should say that CC translations are not sufficiently guaranteed to be accurate and thus should not be copied to this wiki. (NB: the guaranee is lacking, not the quality.) As for official translations, I think the present practice of labelling the translation column as "official" is enough.

Templates IMHO needlessly take up space and draw too much attention. If there are too many, readers will start ignoring them. Furthermore, they may get out of date. A song without a CC translation when the page is created may get one later, or the uploader may decide to delete one they didn't like. I don't think it's feasible to keep these templates up to date.